The defense of divination the science of predicting the future offered in book 1 is illustrated with many entertaining anecdotes that make the argument more accessible to a wider range of readers than many of ciceros other. Anaximander, son of praxiades, was born in the third year of the 42nd olympiad 610 bc. The book of fate, formerly in the possession of napoleon, rendered into english from a german translation of an ancient egyptian manuscript. In this new translation of, and commentary on, book one the first in english for over 80 years david wardle guides the reader through the course of cicero s argument, giving particular attention to the traditional roman and the philosophical conception of divination. According to apollodorus of athens, greek grammarian of the 2nd century bc, he was sixtyfour years old during the second year of the 58th olympiad 547546 bc, and died shortly afterwards establishing a timeline of his work is now impossible, since no document provides chronological references.
The veterinary journal is available online only to january 1984 volume 140, issue 1 of what was then called the british veterinary. Edited by david wardle clarendon ancient history series. The defense of divination the science of predicting the future offered in book 1 is illustrated with many entertaining anecdotes that make the argument more accessible to a wider range of readers than many of cicero s other philosophical works. In the prologue of book i, cicero begins the text by defining divination as the. On divinationbook 1 wikisource, the free online library. Expansion and first english translation of the italian scholars influential 1984 work. In this new translation of, and commentary on, book onethe first in english for over 80 yearsdavid wardle guides. His political stance was sharply criticized for inconsistency by theodor mommsen and others, his philosophical works for lack of originality. Its very hard to imagine a modern author that would take such a long time to make explicit the view of the ones they want to oppose. A really splendid and helpful thing it is if only such a faculty.
Read the fulltext online edition of cicero on divination. Cicero s treatment of grecoroman philosophy and religion furnished christian apologists with arguments that were all the more effective because they were based on a universally acknowledged authority. A truly splendid and serviceable gift, if it only exists in reality. A really amazing book by cicero discussing divination. Cicero the latin library the classics page the latin library the classics page. At the same time recent years have seen an intensive study of hellenistic philosophy, and this has shown more clearly than before that, even while following greek models, cicero nonetheless pursued his own political and, in the ethical works, moralistic agenda. The theological efforts of the roman upper classes in the first. Book i deals with quintus apology of divination in line with his essentially stoic beliefs, while book ii contains ciceros refutation of. Toward the end of the last century ciceros work came under attack from several angles. Against the manichees and on the literal interpretation of genesis. Indeed, one can only wish to write a book as scholarly as this. The first half of it is dedicated to arguments in favor of divination and the second half to arguments against it. A political and literary biography being a contribution to the history of ancient civilization and a guide to the study of cicero s writings by e. Oracles, prophecies, dreams and divination kmbedigan.
Sanders is an american theologian who is a professor of religious studies at hendrix college. In discussions of cicero and religion one should avoid the temptation to. Cicero for and against divination volume 76 malcolm schofield. Laws history is the witness that testifies to the passing of time. Weekly book list, january 9, 2015 the chronicle of higher. Read, highlight, and take notes, across web, tablet, and phone. Amphilochus et mopsus argivorum reges fuerunt, sed iidem augures, iique urbis in ora maritima ciliciae graecas condiderunt, but this is just the sort of information he could have picked up during his proconsulship in cilicia in. Skeptics has not escaped the notice of contemporary bayesians jeffrey 1984.
The book is divided into a long introduction on the topica, the ancient locitheory, the peripatetic sources of the work, its legal aspects and its transmission pp. Dyck situates cicero s text in the context of roman religion in antiquity, and he traces the subsequent reception of the text. Tullius cicero, divination, divination book i, section 1. Marcus tullius cicero, topica edited with translation.
Beware of greeks bearing giftsan evocative statement which still resonates today. The annenberg cpbproject provided support for entering this text. David wardle provides a new translation, an introduction. Cicero may allude to greek traditions according to which the city was founded by. Cambridge core institutional access books catalogue individuals. It takes the form of a dialogue whose interlocutors are cicero himself speaking mostly in book ii and his brother quintus. Translated with an introduction and historical commentary. Cicero 106 bce 43 bce was a lawyer and public figure who undertook the senatorial cursus honorum, reaching the consulship in 63 bce.
He was subsequently involved in the civil war between pompey and caesar before falling victim to the purge of the second triumvirate octavian, lepidus, mark antony. Prophecies and the desire to predict the future appear frequently in antiquity and present a fascinating insight into the social, political and religious life of the ancient world. Cicero, a roman statesman, lawyer, political theorist, philosopher, and roman constitutionalist, lived from 106 43 bc. There is an ancient belief, handed down to us even from mythical times and firmly established by the general agreement of the roman people and of all nations, that divination of some kind exists among men. Cicero on divination hardcover david wardle oxford. In this new translation of, and commentary on, book one the first in english for over 80 years david wardle guides. It is an old opinion, derived as far back as from the heroic times, and confirmed by the unanimous consent of the roman people, and indeed of all nations, that there is a species of divination in existence among men, which the greeks call.
He was a roman senator and consul chiefmagistrate who played a critical role in the transformation of the roman republic into. Tullius cicero, divination, divination book i, section 48. The writings of marcus tullius cicero constitute one of the most famous bodies of historical and philosophical work in all of classical antiquity. He gives an argument to justify his approach on pp. Weekly book list, january 9, 2015 the chronicle of.
Cicero for and against divination the journal of roman studies. The defense of divination the science of predicting the future offered in book 1 is illustrated with many entertaining anecdotes that make the argument more. Despite this, this book is not only the most complete edition of ciceros topica we have but also, due to the discussion which r. D wardle this is the first english commentary on cicero s on divination book i that is fully accessible to the reader who knows no latin or greek. In this new translation of, and commentary on, book onethe first. Book i deals with quintus a pology of divination in line with his essentially stoic beli efs, while book ii con tains cicero s refutation of these from his. In this new translation of, and commentary on, book one the first.
What is more, it seems that after the break, we could all use. I have suggested, to the contrary, that cicero seems critical of panaetius, which would mean that sourcecriticism may notbe a good approach to ciceros book. A contemporary of julius caesar, cicero is widely considered one of romes greatest orators and prose st. According to apollodorus of athens, greek grammarian of the 2nd century bc, he was sixtyfour years old during the second year of the 58th olympiad 547546 bc, and died shortly afterwards. In the two books ofde divinatione cicero considers beliefs concerning fate and the possibility of prediction. In the first book, ciceros brother quintus offers a cautious defence. An accurate translation makes clear cicero s use of religious terminology and philosophical argument in this important work. The internet classics archive buy loeb classical library. In the first book, cicero s brother quintus offers a cautious defence. Translated with introduction and historical commentary by david.
1187 1529 1293 1388 49 558 878 746 621 53 911 873 818 1149 1006 1307 1244 1400 781 1423 1139 599 642 1382 104 1529 1351 992 605 481 1458 490 840 341 604 109 284 237 533 288 1034